New Analysis Finds Large Drugmakers Could Lose $1 Trillion in Sales and Still Be the Most Profitable Industry
WASHINGTON, DC – November 14, 2019 – A new analysis of publicly reported financial data by researchers at West Health Policy Center and Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health finds that large, brand-name drug manufacturers would still be the most profitable industry sector even with $1 trillion in lower sales, all while maintaining current research investments.
“The pharmaceutical industry has tried to instill fear in the American public that federal legislative proposals to reduce drug spending would threaten access to innovative life-saving drugs,” said Timothy A. Lash, president of the West Health Policy Center. “West Health and John Hopkins’ findings clearly refute that claim. Large drugmakers are so profitable they could maintain their current investment in R&D – and their standing as the most profitable industry – even if they lose significant revenue.”
The new analysis builds on previous research by the Government Accountability Office and the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) that found the pharmaceutical industry has among the highest profit margins and returns of any industry group. For this new analysis, researchers specifically looked at a list of 23 large drug manufacturers, defined as those that mostly market brand-name drugs, are members of the PhRMA trade association, are publicly traded, and do not solely focus on orphan drugs.
Using a measure called Return on Invested Capital (ROIC), which considers a company’s net operating profit after taxes to its total invested capital, researchers compared returns among the large drug manufacturers in the analysis with other industries. They found that from 2011-2019, large drug companies were the most profitable industry, with a combined ROIC of 17.3%; the next most profitable industries (“Accommodation and Food Services” and “Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services”) each had an ROIC of 15.3% and the average ROIC across industries (excluding large drug companies) was 11.5%.
Comparing the large drug manufacturers to the next most profitable industries, researchers concluded these companies could lose $758 billion in sales revenue and still be more profitable than any other industry. Adjusting the analysis to apply to all brand name drug manufacturers – since the 23 companies in the analysis represent 72% of branded sales – the researchers determined all brand name drug companies could collectively lose $1.05 trillion in sales revenue and still be more profitable than any other industry.
“Given these findings, it’s likely large drug manufacturers could weather the reductions in drug spending scored under recent legislative proposals,” said Sean Dickson, director of health policy at West Health Policy Center and lead author for the analysis. “Even with lower revenues, these companies would still be very attractive investment options compared to other industries.”
The researchers also examined the level of investor risk among large drug manufacturers, using a financial indicator called a beta, which measures the volatility of a company’s performance to the stock market as a whole. (A beta of 1 means a company or industry tracks the market exactly, while a beta above 1 is a more volatile investment than average and a beta below 1 is a less-risky investment.) They found the large drug companies in the analysis were less risky than 75% of other industries (with a sales-weighted average beta of .61).
“The large drug companies in our analysis were not a particularly risky investment, while smaller drug companies expectedly were, with a beta of .93,” said Jeromie Ballreich, director of the Masters in Health Economics and Outcomes Research program at Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health and co-author of the analysis. “These findings refute a common critique that big drug companies need large profits given the high risk involved in developing prescription drugs.”
To download the full report, click here.
About the West Health Policy Center and West Health
Solely funded by philanthropists Gary and Mary West, West Health is a family of nonprofit and nonpartisan organizations including the Gary and Mary West Foundation and Gary and Mary West Health Institute in San Diego, and the Gary and Mary West Health Policy Center in Washington, D.C. West Health is dedicated to lowering healthcare costs to enable seniors to successfully age in place with access to high-quality, affordable health and support services that preserve and protect their dignity, quality of life and independence. Learn more at westhealth.org and follow @WestHealth.
Director of Public Affairs
Director of Communications
Extending Medicare Part D rebates to beneficiaries would save seniors $29 billion over 7 years Healthcare Finance News
Extending Medicare Part D Rebates To Beneficiaries Would Save Seniors $29 Billion Over 7 Years Eurasia Review
Extending Medicare Part D rebates to beneficiaries would save seniors $29 billion over 7 years EurekAlert!
Extending Medicare Part D rebates to beneficiaries would save seniors $29 billion over seven years MyHeadlinez
Extending Medicare Part D rebates to beneficiaries would save seniors $29 billion over seven years Medical Xpress
New assessment quantifies the financial impact of Medicare Part D program News Medical and Life Science
Extending Medicare Part D rebates to beneficiaries would save seniors $29 billion over 7 years Science Codex
Passing Rebates to Medicare Part D Beneficiaries Could Save Them $29 Billion, Report Says AJMC
Opinion: New drug development: ‘It’s the ecosystem, stupid’ STAT
Big Pharma Could Lose $1 Trillion In Sales & Still Be The Most Profitable Industry World Health Network
Dec 6 – big pharma criminal mafia could….”lose” $1 trillion and still make money Boxden
Time to put patients before profits The Hill
What lower prices would mean for drug companies Axios
Drugmakers could lose $1T in sales and still be most profitable industry, analysis finds Becker’s Hospital Review
Drugmakers could lose $1T and still be profitable Healthcare Finance News
Analysis finds big drugmakers could lose $1 trillion in sales and still be most profitable industry Medical Xpress
New Analysis Finds Large Drugmakers Could Lose $1 Trillion In Sales And Still Be The Most Profitable Industry ABC6
Analysis finds big drugmakers could lose $1 trillion in sales and still be most profitable industry EurekAlert!
New Analysis Finds Large Drugmakers Could Lose $1 Trillion in Sales and Still Be the Most Profitable Industry West Health press release
Drug majors most profitable industry sector, report finds The Pharma Letter
New Analysis Finds Large Drugmakers Could Lose ADVFN Deutschland
Science X Newsletter Thursday, Nov 14 The EDGE
Drugmakers could still profit with a $1T loss Health Exec
Survey Looks at Death Rate Among Americans Due to Inability to Pay for Care Physicians News Network
Axios: Lower Drug Prices Would Obliterate Profits And Research? Maybe Not Kaiser Health News
Big Pharma companies could lose $1 trillion–and still be more profitable than other industries Benefits Pro
Consumers Left Paying For Pricey Brand-Name Drugs Even As Generics Approvals Jump. What’s Going Wrong? Kaiser Health News
Time to put patients before profits The Hill